537 Railroad Street St. Johnsbury, Vermont - For Sale

537 Railroad Street St. Johnsbury, Vermont 05819 MLS# 5067317

Return to your Search ResultsBack to Search Results Next PropertyView the next property

For Sale Status

$799,950 List Price

House Type

2 Beds

3 Baths

10,826 Sqft

Listed By Mathew Ghafoori of RE/Max Heritage
🖶

View Market Report

Mortgage Provider

Contact a local mortgage provider today to get pre-approved.

Call: (866) 805-6267
NMLS# 446767

Get Pre-Approved »

Mortgage Calculator

$

$ Taxes

$ Principal & Interest

$

This calculation is based on a rough estimate. Every person's situation is different. Be sure to consult with a mortgage advisor on your specific needs.

537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street
537 Railroad Street

Welcome to this truly unique property in the heart of downtown St. Johnsbury. This one-of-a-kind building offers potential for residential conversion, live-work, or creative mixed use. Originally built as a church, this building offers a one-of-a-kind opportunity to create your dream residence. The structure retains many original architectural features - soaring ceilings, large windows, classic trims, and an open floor-plan with flexible layout possibilities, the expansive square footage allows for endless design options. The second floor offers a full indoor basketball court that could easily be converted to a pickleball court, ideal for fitness enthusiasts, hosting guests, or countless other uses. Adding to its character, the property is complete with a historic church bell, and intricate stain-glass windows that flood the space with color and light, showcasing the property's artistry and craftsmanship. Perfectly situated in a prominent downtown location in the heart of St. Johnsbury, you'll enjoy convenient access to shops, schools, dining, and local attractions. The adaptive nature of the space offers tremendous potential, and a rare opportunity to own a truly unique property in the historic Village of Saint Johnsbury.

Video Property Tour

Property Location

537 Railroad Street St. Johnsbury

Property Details

List Price  $799,950 Total Rooms  19 List Date  Oct 25th, 2025
Cooperation Fee  Unknown Lot Size  0.4 Acres Taxes $11,651
MLS#  5067317 Days on Market  222 Days Tax Year 2025
Type  House Stories  2 Road Frontage  276
Bedrooms  2 Style  Historic Vintage, Other Water Frontage  
Full Bathrooms  0 Finished  10,826 Sqft Construction  No, Existing
3/4 Bathrooms  0 Above Grade  10,826 Sqft Seasonal  No
Half Bathrooms  3 Below Grade  0 Sqft Year Built  1851
1/4 Bathrooms  0 Garage Size   Car County  Caledonia
Interior Features
Equipment & Appliances
ConstructionWood Frame, Vinyl Siding
BasementDirt Floor, Partial, Exterior Stairs, Interior Stairs, Unfinished
Exterior Features
Disability Features
Foundation   House Color  
Floors   Building Certifications  
Roof  Metal HERS Index  
DirectionsThe property is located at the corner of Railroad and Maple Streets in downtown, St. Johnsbury.
Lot DescriptionCorner, Level, Major Road Frontage, Sidewalks, In Town, Near Shopping
Garage & Parking  
Road Frontage Type  Paved,Public,Public Maintained Road Water Access  
Suitable Use Water Type  
Driveway  Paved Water Body  
Flood Zone  No Zoning  Commercial
School District  St. Johnsbury School District Middle  St. Johnsbury Schools
Elementary  St. Johnsbury Schools High  Choice
Heating  Oil, Radiator, Steam Items Excluded  
Cooling  Central AC Negotiable  
Sewer  Metered, Public Parcel Access ROW  
Water  Metered, Public ROW for Other Parcel  
Water Heater   Financing  
Cable Co   Documents  
Electric  Circuit Breaker(s) Tax ID  558-176-11984
Loading

† The remarks published on this webpage originate from Listed By Mathew Ghafoori of RE/Max Heritage via the PrimeMLS IDX Program and do not represent the views and opinions of Coldwell Banker Hickok & Boardman. Coldwell Banker Hickok & Boardman cannot be held responsible for possible violations of copyright resulting from the posting of any data from the PrimeMLS IDX Program.