2537 Malletts Bay Avenue Colchester, Vermont - Under Contract

2537 Malletts Bay Avenue Colchester, Vermont 05446 MLS# 5087582

Return to your Search ResultsBack to Search Results Next PropertyView the next property

Under Contract Status

$714,900 List Price

Multi Type

6 Beds

4 Baths

3,207 Sqft

Listed By Mikail Stein of RE/MAX North Professionals
🖶

View Market Report

Mortgage Provider

Contact a local mortgage provider today to get pre-approved.

Call: (866) 805-6267
NMLS# 446767

Get Pre-Approved »

Mortgage Calculator

$

$ Taxes

$ Principal & Interest

$

This calculation is based on a rough estimate. Every person's situation is different. Be sure to consult with a mortgage advisor on your specific needs.

Colchester

2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue
2537 Malletts Bay Avenue

With $150,000 in updates this property is looking for it's next owners! With over 3200 finished sqft, 6 total bedrooms and 4 total baths this could be a owner occupied home, or a fantastic investment property. The current owners poured their hearts into this home with major updates to the kitchen (including everything from the cabinets to the lighting and appliances) new full bath, the addition of a Mitsubishi Mini Split, new washer and dryer, updating trim and painting throughout, recently serviced gas heaters, new chimney liner, they removed and repaired drop ceilings, replaced the front window, landscaping, and more! In the larger unit (2600sqft+) you'll find split level living with 4 bedrooms and 2.5 baths. The upstairs primary bedroom has it's own 1/2 bath. The smaller unit, with vaulted ceilings, has 2 bedrooms and a full bath with it's own washer and dryer as well. There is a 2 car garage set up so that each bay is separate. The almost 3/4 of an acre is broken into 2 private yards split by privacy fencing between each unit. Estimated rental numbers put this property at a CAP rate of 7.86% or just over $56,000/yr in net profit. Only 1.3 Miles to the Winooski circle makes the town an easy visit, and Burlington's Church Street is only 3.8 miles or a 10 minute commute away. Lake Champlain's Bayside Park in Colchester is 3 miles up the road and great skiing is as close as 30 minutes away. Open house is planned for Saturday 5/9/26 from 10:30am to 1pm, please feel free to stop by!

Property Location

2537 Malletts Bay Avenue Colchester

Property Details

Contract Date  May 9th, 2026
List Price  714,900 Bedrooms  6 Garage Size  2 Car
Cooperation Fee  Unknown Total Bathrooms  4 Year Built  1968
MLS#  5087582 Lot Size  0.68 Acres Taxes $6,452
Type  Multi-Family Days on Market  47 Days Tax Year 2025
Units  2 Stories  1/1/1900 Road Frontage  
Annual Income  $68,400 Style  Private Water Frontage  
Annual Expenses  $0 Finished  3,207 Sqft Construction  No, Existing
Zoning   rez Above Grade  2,063 Sqft Seasonal  No
Total Rooms  6 Below Grade  1,144 Sqft List Date  May 7th, 2026
Gross Income  $68,400 Operating Expenses  $0 Net Income  $56,159
Expenses Includes 
Unit 1   4 Beds, 3 Baths, 2,607 SqFt, $3,500/Monthly Unit 2   2 Beds, 1 Baths, 600 SqFt, $2,200/Monthly
Construction
BasementInterior, Finished
Interior Features
Exterior Features
Exterior   Disability Features  
Foundation   House Color  
Floors   Building Certifications  
Roof  Shingle HERS Index  
DirectionsFrom the Winooski Circle go North on Main Street towards Colchester. Right onto West Spring St. Right on to Malletts Bay Ave, property will be on right hand side.
Lot Description, Near Hospital, Near School(s)
Garage & Parking  Yes
Road Frontage   Water Access  
Driveway  Paved Water Type  
Flood Zone  No Water Body  
Zoning  rez
School District  Colchester School District Middle  Colchester Middle School
Elementary  Malletts Bay Elementary School High  Colchester High School
Heat Fuel  , Electric Excluded  
Heating/Cool  Mini Split, Electric, Direct Vent Negotiable  
Sewer  Septic Parcel Access ROW  
Water   ROW for Other Parcel  
Water Heater   Financing  
Cable Co  Burlington Telecom Documents  
Electric  Circuit Breaker Tax ID  153-048-18867
Loading

† The remarks published on this webpage originate from Listed By Mikail Stein of RE/MAX North Professionals via the PrimeMLS IDX Program and do not represent the views and opinions of Coldwell Banker Hickok & Boardman. Coldwell Banker Hickok & Boardman cannot be held responsible for possible violations of copyright resulting from the posting of any data from the PrimeMLS IDX Program.